The Supreme Court levied a blow to the Trump administration on Monday as it refused to review a federal ruling that keeps the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, or DACA, partially alive.

Though well received, immigration advocates have cautioned that the victory will be short-lived unless Congress takes meaningful action to address the fate of so-called Dreamers.

In its dismissal, the Court said the government’s appeal of California District Judge William Alsup’s January ruling—which declared Trump’s attempt to end DACA illegal—should go through the regular process and be taken up first by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

The White House responded in force, arguing that DACA “is clearly unlawful” and Alsup’s ruling is “a usurpation of legislative authority.”Essentially, the Court’s denial keeps Alsup’s injunction intact, allowing the nearly 700,000 current DACA recipients to renew their work and study permits at least until the Ninth Circuit rules on the government’s appeal sometime later this summer.

For Mariaelena Hincapié, executive director of the National Immigration Law Center, a pro-immigrant advocacy group based in Washington, D.C. that’s good news.

“This was a great morning for Dreamers and their families,” she said.

According to Hincapié, whose organization represents a plaintiff in a separate federal case in New York that also ruled Trump’s attempt to end DACA was illegal earlier this month, the Court’s refusal to let the government skip part of the appeals process illustrates the judicial branch’s ability to undermine the President’s agenda.

“These legal challenges have resulted in important victories for immigrant communities,” she said. “In denying the request to hear the California case, the Supreme Court has allowed our clients to have their day in court. The government has a right to appeal, but they tried to game the system by leapfrogging over the Circuit court.”

In Trump’s criticism of the decision Monday, he again took a shot at the country’s court system, reserving particular ire for the Ninth Circuit court, which has already frustrated the president’s attempts to institute a travel ban.

“You know, we tried to get it moved quickly ’cause we’d like to help DACA,” he said during a meeting of state governors. “I think everybody in this room wants to help with DACA, but the Supreme Court just ruled that it has to go through the normal channels, so it’s going back in. There won’t be any surprise. I mean, it’s really sad when every single case filed against us—this is in the 9th Circuit—we lose, we lose, we lose, and then we do fine in the Supreme Court. But what does that tell you about our court system? It’s a very, very sad thing. So DACA’s going back, and we’ll see what happens from there.”

Yet immigrant rights advocates warn that without Congressional action, these short-term reprieves will not last.”Today’s ruling does not mean much for immigrants who do not qualify for DACA,” Greisa Martinez, policy and advocacy director for United We Dream, an immigrant rights group, said. “Trump and [Attorney General Jeff] Session are bullies—their goal is to not allow one more immigrant be protected under DACA. We need a permanent solution.”

To Martinez, the best course of action is to pass a narrow legislative recourse that protects immigrant youth from deportation and grants them a viable path towards citizenship.

Until then, Dreamers and their families will live in fear of deportation.

“This administration has shown that they are aggressive,” she said. “We are [dealing] with…someone who has aligned with white supremacist groups.”

So far, Republicans and the White House have pushed for drastic reductions in legal immigration and billions of dollars for border enforcement measures in exchange for granting immigrant youth a decade-long path to citizenship.

But many Democrats and immigration advocates have balked at the GOP’s offer, arguing that pitting one immigrant group against another is not the way forward.

“When you’re talking about the communities Trump is going after, you’re talking about Dreamers’ parents and their families,” Anu Joshi, policy director at The New York Immigration Coalition, said. “This administration wants to reframe this country by cutting legal immigration in half. That’s not something we’re willing to bargain away. Immigrant communities make us strong as a country.”

For his part, Trump has claimed that Democrats have not been pursuing the issue nearly as much as they have suggested.

“Senate Democrats and the House Democrats have totally abandoned DACA,” he said during his speech Friday at the Conservative Political Action Conference. “They don’t even talk to me about it, they’ve totally abandoned it,”

It is unlikely Congress will act before the March 5 deadline, given that the federal injunctions keeping DACA alive will be in place for at least a few months.


Schedule Your Consultation Now


All fields are required. Florida Immigration Law Counsel is a law firm. However, the use of the internet or this form for communication with us does not establish an attorney-client relationship. We will discuss your options with you.

More Posts

More Posts

Attorney Saman Movassaghi, Esq.

Caring and compassionate, Saman Movassaghi Gonzalez is a Florida immigration attorney dedicated to producing the results her clients need. She has over 17 years of experience helping both corporate and individual clients with an emphasis in employment/investment cases and family adjustment cases.

As the Managing Attorney at Florida Immigration Law Counsel, Saman Movassaghi Gonzalez and her team are capable of representing and helping individuals looking to attain a Family VisaWork Visa, and Citizenship/Naturalization. Her experience successfully representing clients in front of the Department of Justice for cases involving Deportation/Removal Proceedings will lead to success in your case.

Her experience and expertise in immigration litigation has led to multiple Avvo awards and other accolades, including the Clients’ Choice for 2017 Immigration Attorney. Her clients also consistently post positive reviews on her Facebook page. Her experience has also allowed her to teach a new generation of lawyers as an adjunct professor of law at Nova Southeastern University, and she also regularly gives speeches on immigration matters.

Counselor Gonzalez is also experienced in helping corporate clients through the process of filing for Employment Visas, Labor Certifications, and Business and Investment Visas with the Department of Labor. She takes on the entire case from start to finish, simplifying the process for her clients and allowing them to focus on their business.

Fluent in English, Spanish, and Farsi – Saman Movassaghi Gonzalez is dedicated to making her clients feel comfortable and assured in making her their go-to immigration attorney in Florida. Her goal is to ensure that those who want to live the American dream have a professional fighting for them and making the process as painless as possible.

Saman’s passion for immigration law stems from her personal life as the daughter of immigrants. Her parents were recipients of the student F1 visa in 1971. Her father came into this country with the goal to improve his life and the life of his children. He earned a PhD in Civil Engineering and Business, instilling in his daughter a strong work ethic that she carries to this day. Saman saw firsthand what it means to be an immigrant and achieve the American Dream.

Saman Movassaghi Gonzalez can personally understand the struggle of immigrants and the children of immigrants navigating through the bureaucratic process of immigration law. Because of this, she dedicates herself fully and provides her personal attention to every case. She prides herself on developing a strong relationship with each and every client, and she is not afraid of pushing the envelope and looking for answers where other attorneys have failed.

Saman Movassaghi makes it her goal to provide you with only the best representation for immigration matters because she believes it’s time for you to live the American dream!